• David Howells's avatar
    [PATCH] WorkStruct: Use direct assignment rather than cmpxchg() · 4594bf15
    David Howells authored
    Use direct assignment rather than cmpxchg() as the latter is unavailable
    and unimplementable on some platforms and is actually unnecessary.
    
    The use of cmpxchg() was to guard against two possibilities, neither of
    which can actually occur:
    
     (1) The pending flag may have been unset or may be cleared.  However, given
         where it's called, the pending flag is _always_ set.  I don't think it
         can be unset whilst we're in set_wq_data().
    
         Once the work is enqueued to be actually run, the only way off the queue
         is for it to be actually run.
    
         If it's a delayed work item, then the bit can't be cleared by the timer
         because we haven't started the timer yet.  Also, the pending bit can't be
         cleared by cancelling the delayed work _until_ the work item has had its
         timer started.
    
     (2) The workqueue pointer might change.  This can only happen in two cases:
    
         (a) The work item has just been queued to actually run, and so we're
             protected by the appropriate workqueue spinlock.
    
         (b) A delayed work item is being queued, and so the timer hasn't been
         	 started yet, and so no one else knows about the work item or can
         	 access it (the pending bit protects us).
    
         Besides, set_wq_data() _sets_ the workqueue pointer unconditionally, so
         it can be assigned instead.
    
    So, replacing the set_wq_data() with a straight assignment would be okay
    in most cases.
    
    The problem is where we end up tangling with test_and_set_bit() emulated
    using spinlocks, and even then it's not a problem _provided_
    test_and_set_bit() doesn't attempt to modify the word if the bit was
    set.
    
    If that's a problem, then a bitops-proofed assignment will be required -
    equivalent to atomic_set() vs other atomic_xxx() ops.
    Signed-off-by: default avatarDavid Howells <dhowells@redhat.com>
    Signed-off-by: default avatarLinus Torvalds <torvalds@osdl.org>
    4594bf15
workqueue.c 20.7 KB